Bobcats best Cardinals with fourth-quarter fireworks in 35-28 victory

Ohio rallies, extending the nation's longest home winning streak to 18 games

Share
Bobcats best Cardinals with fourth-quarter fireworks in 35-28 victory
Photo credit: APocketJoker (used under Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 license via Wikimedia Commons)

The Ball State Cardinals (3-8, 2-5 MAC) came out of the gate with an impressive display of fight, physicality, and– at times– execution. Alas, they were were unable to seal the deal in the end, racing out to a first-half lead before allowing the Ohio Bobcats (8-3, 6-1 MAC) to turn the tables in the second half to keep their title game hopes alive.

Offenses who struggled at times last week opened with haymakers to start, lighting up the scoreboard early.

The first play of Ohio's first offensive drive was a 46-yard bomb from QB Nick Poulos to wideout Riley Neer, who beat the safety deep on a double move. Ohio's Poulos was key for the rest of the drive, picking up 11 yards on the ground and a 16-yard strike to Neer in a small window. Running back Duncan Brune did the rest with 11 yards on two runs for a score, his sixth rushing touchdown of the season.

The Cardinals responded with a long pass of its own from quarterback Keldric Luster to receiver Elisha Durham for 33 yards. Luster went to the ground and chewed up another 29 yards on four carries. However, in the redzone, BSU could not convert for a touchdown.

The Cardinals dialed up a receiver throw off a reverse, which worked for a touchdown for Miami last week against Ohio– but Ohio cornerback Kendall Bannister was well positioned to thwart BSU's attempt. The drive stalled around the five-yard line when a false start pushed the Cards back and they could not convert third down. With Brady Boehm hitting 50 percent on field goal attempt this season, Ball State brought in new kicker Hudson Fiene who calmly nailed his first career BSU attempt from 24 yards out.

The offenses traded punts after that, with Ohio unable to convert some additional explosives or get the running game going. After moving to Ohio's territory, self-inflicted wounds resurfaced with an offensive pass interference squelching a promising Ball State drive.

The visiting Cards would find their footing midway though the second quarter, as Luster's play set up a 10-yard touchdown strike to Donovan Hamilton to go up 10-7, then extend that lead to 17-7 on an 80-yard touchdown by Eli Hohlt set up by a heady interception by Quentavius Scandrett in the endzone.

Looking to stop the bleeding, the 'Cats found their running game near the end of the first half. After a 15-yard penalty for defensive personal foul, Ohio ran the ball six-straight times to cover the remaining 60 yards. Ohio punched it in from eight yards on a Poulos keeper, moving the score 17-14.

BSU got the last laugh of the first half with a little over a minute left, driving 59 yards to set up kicker Hudson Fiene hit a clutch 43-yard field goal for a 20-14 halftime lead. Luster dominated the initial action with some spirited runs up the middle, moving the pile at times to advance the Cards' cause.

The Cardinal offense had Ohio's number in the first half, running amok for a combined 326 yards. Excluding the busted play for 80-yards, the visitors wound up with an impressive 246 combined yards.

BSU initially picked up where they left off to start the second half as well, gashing Ohio for multiple first downs into Ohio territory, but the Ohio defense which has defined the team came to its senses, turning the tide with DJ Walker's strip fumble to kill the Cardinal momentum and give the Bobcats offense the ball back.

After that drive, Ohio's defense forced two three-and-out punts, sandwiching a Darren James-Hamiltion interception return from 39 yards out to put the Bobbies back in control at a 21-20 margin.

Just prior to the James-Hamilton interception, Ohio had a key offensive drive in the grand scheme. Looking for a spark and with packages at the ready, the 'Cats went to freshman sensation QB Levi Davis to replace Nick Poulos. The drive had its ups and downs, and did not end in points, but crucially, it drained nine minutes off the clock, slowing the game's pace down and allowing Ohio to dictate the terms of engagement.

At this point, Ball State's initial vim seemed to wane, and Poulos returned to guide his squad to a 28-20 lead. Starting the drive in excellent field position around the 50-yard line, Poulos piloted the crew for a touchdown, acting as the catalyst by completing early passes and rushing for 19 yards late, including a 12-yard rush for score.

Things would not be so easy to finish though, as Luster and company fought back to tie it at 28-all thanks to TJ Horton rushing touchdown late in the fourth quarter.

With the game in the balance, Ohio found a way to win the last two minutes and change to turn away a determined visitor– this time behind a heavy dose of running back Duncan Brune. After Brune and the offensive line converted some first downs, Poulus and company did the rest on a 29-yard strike in the right side of the endzone, where wideout Dom Dorwart made an incredible grab for the score.

Down 35-28, the Cards move to midfield to get a Hail Mary shot at the end of regulation but the ball was batted down in the endzone by DJ Walker to secure the win.


Notes

  • The 2026 Bobcat team so far reminds me of a saying that Pittsburgh Steelers Hall of Fame head coach Chuck Noll was reportedly fond of: "whatever it takes." Just doing what you have to in order to win. Having followed the Bobcats for more seasons than some current players have been alive, I've never seen a squad quite like this one. It is uncanny how they have been able to find a way to win. So far this season, Ohio is 6-1 in games coming down to the wire, including 4-0 in games decided on the final play against Jacksonville State, Kent State, Eastern Michigan and Ball State. However it happens, it is happening, whether it is a freshman QB scoring two in fourth overtime, a defensive stand in the redzone, or a late offensive drive, someone always seems to make the play, even when things don't go smoothly.
  • One of many players to be "that guy" to make critical plays this year is safety Darren James-Hamilton. Whether it is, like this week, a pick-six, a kickoff return touchdown, or key tackles and PBUs, James-Hamilton has been a guy doing whatever it takes to make things come out right on the scoreboard.
  • With due respect to Ohio, the Cardinals probably feel they should have won this. Coming off a rain-soaked game where they didn't score an offensive point, BSU rolled for 448 yards offense and did make progress in the red zone, scoring two touchdowns. The difference was probably self-inflicted wounds in untimely penalties for 70 yards and two turnovers. The margin of error is so small in MAC competition and mistakes can be magnified.
  • BSU fans should be excited about the future of the offense under quarterback Keldric Luster, who played well and with a lot of heart for long stretches tonight. The first year starter led the club with 256 yards passing, two passing touchdowns, and 109 yards rushing.

Next up, Ohio moves on to one of the MAC's biggest games of the year, when the 'Cats host contender Toledo Rockets (8-2, 5-1 MAC) on for a Black Friday afternoon affair. The game is set for kickoff on Friday, November 27th, at noon Eastern time.

Ball State closes out the season at home on Saturday, November 28th, in a noon Eastern time showdown against Central Michigan. The Cards will look to equal their record from last season with a win.